10 Best Eye Primers to Crease-Free Lids All Day Long

Best eye primer
Image credit: Expert Reviews

Eye primer is a must-have beauty product, but it can be tricky to figure out which one to use. There are so many different kinds of eye primers on the market today, and you need to make sure that your eyelids look their best all day long. Whether you have oily lids or sensitive eyes, we’ve got the best eye primer for mature skin at a drugstore that will keep your eyeshadow looking fresh for hours.

Best Eye Primer for Mature Skin

If you have mature skin, you know that a good eye primer is a must. It will help your eyeshadow stay put all day and last longer, giving it that dewy look that everyone loves. Some primers also include SPF benefits, so they’re great for summertime too.

#1. Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Shadow Primer

Elizabeth Mott is one of the best eye primer for mature skin out there. It keeps your eyeshadow in place all day, so it doesn’t crease and the colors stay brighter for longer. The formula is very easy to apply, and it comes in an easy-to-use tube that you can store at any angle or sharpness (which means no more messy brushes).

#2. Milani Eyeshadow Prime-Best Crease-Proof

Milani eyeshadow is a great eye primer for mature skin. It’s lightweight and hydrating, so it does not feel heavy or greasy on your lids. The product has a silky smooth texture and is non-comedogenic (won’t clog pores).

The best part about this eye primer for mature skin is that it contains vitamin E, which helps reduce the appearance of fine lines around your eyes by improving collagen production in the skin. This product also adds an extra boost of hydration to your lids. Also, this eye primer for mature skin can be used as an eyeshadow primer or a base for foundation. Just shake it well before using it each time you apply it to make sure there are no clumps or dry patches left behind from the previous.

#3. Best Waterproof-Too-Faced Shadow Insurance

This is one of the best eye primer for mature skin and people with oily lids who don’t mind the extra product on their faces. The primer has a gel base that keeps your eye shadow in place all day and also prevents creasing, smudging, and fading of your eyelids when you start to sweat or get hot. 

It’s an excellent choice if you’re looking for something lightweight that won’t feel heavy on your face (or if you just don’t like wearing too much makeup).

#4. Best Vegan-Urban Decay Anti-Aging Eyeshadow Primer Potion

This eye primer is great for all skin types, but especially for those with sensitive and mature skin. It’s also vegan and cruelty-free, so you can wear it without worrying about animal testing.

The Urban Decay All-Nighter Foundation Primer Potion is a long-lasting formula that creates a smooth canvas on your lids. It has hydrating ingredients like coconut water and avocado oil, which will help nourish your eye area as well as keep it looking good throughout the day. This waterproof formula will last all day (or night) without creasing or smudging under makeup.

Is Eye Primer Really Necessary?

If you’re looking to avoid crease-free lids all day long, eye primers are not necessary. But if you don’t have very oily lids or wear eye makeup only occasionally. Then they can be an easy way to reduce shine and prevent watery eyes when you do put on your makeup.

If you do enjoy wearing full-coverage foundation or powder contouring products (which is great), then an eye primer will help keep those formulas from sitting on top of your skin instead of absorbing into it as a sponge would. They prevent eyeshadow creases and fading. An eye primer can help waterproof mascara last all day. If you like to wear eyeliner over eyeshadow, a primer will help keep it in place longer.

Also see: J ONE JELLY PACK: Definition, Reviews and How to Use it

Best Eye Primer Drugstore

Drugstore eye primers are a great way to save money on your routine and get the most out of your makeup. While many brands offer more expensive versions, drugstore versions are often just as effective. Hence, if you have oily lids, here are the best eye primer drugstore:

#1. Benefit They’re Real Mascara 

This mascara is one of the most popular ones from Benefit because it gives long-lasting volume and keeps lashes from sticking together. It also has an adjustable brush that helps separate lashes evenly without using clumps or globs of the product (which makes them easier to remove). 

This formula doesn’t sting the eyes like other mascaras can, making it perfect for sensitive eyes like those with dry or aging skin.

#2. Smash Box Photo Finish Hydrating Under Eye Primer

This eye primer from this drugstore is ideal for all skin types, but especially for those with dry or combination skin. It’s a good primer for sensitive or oily under-eye areas, and it can also be used as a concealer if you need it.

So, if you have mature or aging skin, this eye primer will help prevent wrinkles by hydrating and plumping up the upper part of your face (the forehead).

#3. Essence I Love Stage Eyeshadow Base

Essence, which I love for stage eyeshadow, is a great primer for dry skin. It will help keep your makeup in place all day long and prevent creasing, which is especially important if you have dry or sensitive skin. When applying this product to the eyelid, start from the inner corner of your eye and apply it outward toward your temple. This way, it can prevent any clumping of color as well as give your eyeshadow some time before it starts fading away at around 2 hours after application (or sooner). 

You may want to use another brush or a sponge during application so that there isn’t too much product in one spot. Otherwise, if you have oily lids like mine, this might cause some irritation later on.

#4. Milani Eyeshadow Primer

Milani’s eyeshadow primer is good for oily lids, dry lids, and sensitive eyes. It’s also great for all skin tones and eye colors. This product works well as an eyeshadow base because it doesn’t clump or settle into any lines or creases on the eyelid. 

If you have oily skin, this will help keep your face shine-free while adding dimension to the look of your makeup looks by creating a soft focus effect that makes everything pop. You can use this primer alone or add another product over top, like a cream concealer or powder foundation, if you want even more coverage.

Best Eye Primer for Oily Lids

Eye primer is a must for oily lids. If you have oily skin, then it’s important to use an eye primer that has a matte finish. This will help your eyelid stay flat all day and prevent any shine from transferring onto your face. Eyeshadow primer is not the same as an eye primer. It is used to make eyeshadow last longer by making it easier to apply and less likely to smudge.

#1. Bella Terra Mineral Cosmetics Eyeshadow Primer

The eyeshadow primer from Bella Terra mineral cosmetics is a great choice for people who want to put on their makeup quickly and easily. It’s formulated with ingredients that help your eyeshadow stay in place all day, so you don’t have to worry about the crease creeping back into place on your lids later in the day. 

The eye cream is also hydrating, which makes it perfect for dry skin types who struggle with irritation from other products. Apply it directly after applying your base products (we recommend using a brush or sponge), then blend out any excess product with your fingertips or a damp beauty blender before applying shadows overtop as desired.

#2. Monica Ann Beauty Dual Action Eyeshadow Primer

This creamy, lightweight formula helps to reduce the appearance of fine lines and smooth out your eye area. This eye primer for oily lids also makes your eyeshadow last longer because it has jojoba oil and vitamin E in it. The formula is so light that you can apply this primer with a brush or with your fingers (which I recommend). The packaging is beautiful and sleek, making it easy for you to take on the go.

#3. Bellesky Eyeshadow Primer

The Bellesky eyeshadow primer is a creamy, light formula that can be used on the lid or brow bone. It’s formulated with hyaluronic acid and vitamin E for extra moisture, so it will help reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles. This eye primer for oily lids is also free of parabens, sulfates, phthalates, or gluten. However, it does contain artificial colors (such as blue 1 Lake).

To use this primer: Apply a thin layer onto your eyelid area, following the instructions on your container; wait 20 minutes before applying any makeup products over top (you may have to wait longer if you have oilier skin). If you’re looking for an all-day wear option, then apply again after eight hours but avoid rubbing too hard into the delicate eye areas.

#4. Pur Get A Grip Endurance Eyeshadow Primer

If you have oily lids, this eye primer is a good option. It has a matte finish and can be used on its own or mixed with your favorite eyeshadow formula. You may want to use this primer over an eye shadow base (like Urban Decay’s 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil) if you want more coverage than just an all-over application will give you.

This product also works well as a glitter shadow primer because it helps reduce fallout when applying glitter shadows like those from MAC Cosmetics or Urban Decay’s Vice 4 Palette.

Best Eye Primer for Sensitive Eyes

If you have sensitive eyes, it’s important to find a good eye primer. There are many different kinds of primers and they can be really helpful in helping your eyes look great all day long. The best eye primer for sensitive eyes will:

1. Protect the delicate skin around your eyes from irritation or dryness by keeping them hydrated and moisturized.

2. Be gentle enough for those with dry or irritated skin around their eyes. 

3. Not cause any stinging sensation when applied.

#1. Nivea Daily Essentials Express Hydration

Nivea Daily Essentials Express Hydration is a great eye primer that helps to smooth out fine lines and wrinkles, reduce the appearance of pores, and hydrate the sensitive skin around your eyes. It can also be used on its own or under makeup.

When I use this product I always apply it before applying my usual concealer or foundation. This product does not crease in any way, so you don’t need to worry about any unwanted lines or shadows appearing throughout the day. The only issue with this primer is that it doesn’t stay put very long once applied, so make sure you blend well before going out into public again.

#2. Shadow Lock Eyelid Primer

Shadow lock eyelid primer is a gel-based formula that locks shadows in place. It can be used alone or under eyeshadow, but it’s best used as an alternative to eye shadow primer. This eye primer for sensitive eyes is ideal for those who want to skip the step of priming their lids with an additional product. The gel will stay put all day long until you take it off at night, with no creasing.

#3. L’Oreal  Paris Paradise Mascara Primer

L’Oreal Paris Paradise mascara primer is a lightweight formula that helps hold your eyelashes in place. It also helps to keep the eyeshadow in place, as well as other makeup products such as eyeliner and mascara. This eye primer for sensitive eyes has a smooth, creamy texture that makes it easy to put on the lids without clumping or flaking.

L’Oreal Paris Paradise mascara primer can be used as both a primer for lashes and an excellent base for all types of eye make up including shadow, liner, and even bronzer. The lightweight formula allows you to apply this product easily without worrying about having too much product on your brush or smudging it under your eyes before applying anything else onto your face later on.

#4. Rimmel Fix & Perfect Makeup Primer

Rimmel Fix & Perfect Makeup Primer is a great option for sensitive eyes. It’s designed to reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles, while also keeping your makeup on all day long. 

If you’re looking for a primer that will protect against smudges and creases, this one is perfect. You can use it on its own or under makeup, the choice is yours.

Best Eye Primer for Hooded Eyes

Eye primers are designed to prevent creasing, which is when eyeliner or eyeshadow flakes off during the day. But a good primer can also help your makeup last longer, which means you spend less time reapplying it throughout the day. If you have hooded eyes, it’s especially important to invest in an eye primer that works for those types of lashes.

#1. Barry M cosmetics Lid Lock Eyeshadow Primer

Barry M Cosmetics Lid Lock Eyeshadow Primer is a gel primer that’s made to help your eyeshadow stay in place all day. It has a similar consistency to Urban Decay’s 24/7 Eye Pencil, but it comes in a tube instead of a pencil shape. This makes it easy to use and less messy than using an eye pencil wand on your eyelids.

The packaging also makes this product much more convenient than UD’s version, it comes with a built-in sharpener at the top of the tube that can be used when you’re ready for another application or need some extra precision when applying color directly onto your lids (which I’ve found useful). 

You also won’t have any issues getting this product out of its packaging once you’ve opened it up. Just twist off one end first, then pull down firmly until everything snaps back together again around itself securely.

#2. KIKO Milano Neutral Eye Base

This is a great option for people who want to keep their eyes looking natural but also want to take advantage of all the benefits of a primer. The formula is made to give you a smooth base for your makeup and keep you hydrated for a long time. 

It doesn’t contain any alcohol or fragrance, so it won’t dry out your eyes or make them look cakey. It also has watermelon extract, which can help reduce puffiness, and cucumber extract, which helps get rid of wrinkles.

#3. Advanced Eye-Fix Primer

Advanced eye-fix Primer is a water-based primer that can be used on all skin types. It’s suitable for oily and sensitive skin, as well as dry or combination ones. This primer is hypoallergenic, paraben-free, and fragrance-free, so you don’t have to worry about any negative effects from using it. It also contains vitamin E and aloe vera to moisturize and soothe the skin around your eyes area.

In addition to its gentle ingredients, Advanced Eye Fix Primer provides long-lasting wear thanks to its smooth texture which doesn’t leave creases behind even after hours of wearing makeup.

#4. Miracle Prep Eyeshadow Primer

Miracle prep eyeshadow Primer is a gel-based primer that helps to lock in color and prevent creasing. It can be used on the eyelids and as a base for eyeshadows, so it’s great for creating an even canvas on which you can layer your eye makeup. 

This product also helps with blending, which is important because it makes sure that no matter how much effort you put into applying your makeup (or how long it takes), there will still be no creases in sight.


In this article, we share with you our top 10 eye primers that keep your lids crease-free all day. These eye primers are formulated with ingredients like hyaluronic acid and vitamin C which work together to help your skin look younger for longer. We hope you find this list useful and helpful in choosing the best eye primer for your needs.

Best Eye Primer FAQs

Should eyeliner go on top or bottom?

Keep the liner on the top lid for a more lifted, youthful effect.

  • Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner.
  • Revlon So Fierce Vinyl Eyeliner.
  • Pat McGrath Precision Liquid Liner.

Do you put mascara on before or after eyeliner?

Mascara always lasts after eye shadow and liner as you want to keep it clean with no particles in it.


  • stylecraze.com – 11 Best Eye Primers For Mature Skin To Fight Fine Lines
  • www.expertreviews – Best Eye Primer 2022: Ensure Your Eyeshadow Stays Crease-Free All Day Long
  • byrdie.com – 11 Color-Intensifying Eyeshadow Primers You Can Get at the Drugstore
  • momjunction.com – 15 Best Eyeshadow Primers For Oily Lids In 2022
  • msn.com – 10 Best Eye Primer For Sensitive Eyes 
  • www.amazon – Eyelid Primers For Hooded Eyes

We Also Recommend

  1. Eyeliner or Eyeshadow First?
  2. J ONE JELLY PACK: Definition, Reviews and How to Use them
  3. Eyeshadow for Redheads
  4. Best Tinted Moisturizer for Tinted Skin
  5. Best Liquid Eyeliner for a Glossy Makeup Look

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like